Old Colonial Inn

Nestled within a charming, historic building at 216 N 3rd St in Kentland, Indiana, the Old Colonial Inn offers a refined fine dining experience that beautifully marries classic elegance with comfort. This enchanting restaurant transports you back in time, featuring vintage décor and cozy seating areas like the intimate library room, perfect for an evening of relaxed sophistication.

The cuisine at Old Colonial Inn showcases a thoughtfully curated menu that delights with a balance of hearty classics and decadent indulgences. Meats and seafood take center stage with exquisite dishes such as the perfectly cooked Filet Mignon, the rich and tender New York Strip Steak, and the luxurious Steak and Lobster Tail Combination, a market favorite. For seafood lovers, the Grilled Salmon and delicate Shrimp and Pasta dishes are outstanding options that melt in your mouth.

Soups like the velvety Mushroom Soup and savory Potato Soup warm the senses, setting the tone for a full-bodied meal. Side dishes such as the fluffy Baked Potato add familiar comfort while perfectly complementing the richer mains. And no meal at Old Colonial Inn would be complete without indulging your sweet tooth—the Chocolate Mousse, moist Chocolate Cake, and creamy Raspberry White Chocolate Cheesecake receive high praise from patrons seeking a decadent finish.

Beverage offerings also impress, featuring an elegant selection of wines by the glass, sophisticated cocktails including the classic Brandy Alexander and Martini, plus a curated list of premium brandies such as Remy Martin Rs and Christian Brothers. For those who prefer craft beers or ciders, options like Three Floyds Robert The Bruce, Blue Moon, and Angry Orchard add further variety to your dining experience.

Guests consistently rave about the atmosphere, highlighting the warm, historic ambiance that sets Old Colonial Inn apart from typical dining spots. The attentive staff enhances the experience, with servers like Liz providing informative and personalized recommendations that make each visit memorable. While some have noted the dining pace to be leisurely, the overall consensus embraces this as part of the enjoyable, unhurried charm where great food and company are savored without rush.

Whether you’re seeking a romantic night out, a special celebration, or simply a delicious meal in a setting steeped in history, Old Colonial Inn invites you to savor every bite and moment. As one delighted guest put it, it’s “private club luxury with reasonable, small town prices,” making it a treasured gem in Kentland’s culinary scene.

Reservations are recommended, especially on busy evenings, to ensure you don’t miss out on the impeccable fare and classic ambiance that keep guests returning time and again.